Movie Review: “Censored Voices” | Sophie Xi

After meeting with my mentor Teacher Pat last Thursday, I have decided to take a detour from my study on literature under communism and explore the threat of censorship in storytelling. In the wake of local governments’ interference with freedom of press and speech, many people’s stories of hardships are either hidden or distorted. Through this perspective, I have examined a new type of struggle among people. What’s more, this aspect of knowledge helps me to be more prepared for the future interviews I conduct with family members who experienced the Cultural Revolution.

cv12

Over this past weekend, out of Teacher Pat’s recommendation, I watched the documentary Censored Voices, directed by Israeli filmmaker Mor Lousy. This film depicts the soldiers’ anguish in the Six-Day War of 1967, a historical event in which Israel defeated the armies of Egypt, Syria and Jordan and expanded its territory. After the war ended, in search for a series of first-hand experience in battlefields, author Amos Oz and editor Avraham Shapira recorded conversations with soldiers who just returned home. Their focus was on the soldiers’ emotions rather than their achievements. The Israeli army, however, permitted only 30 percent of the recordings to be released at that time. Until recently, director Mor Lousy discovered these censored conversations and decided to publish them in order to reframe the victorious narrative of war in 1967.

The soldiers’ recounts of the war were filled with fear, horror and loathing. One soldier commented on his ruthless commander who instructed them to “show no mercy. Kill as many as possible.” Another returning soldiers left a profound remark that “war complicated them in a way that will be very hard to solve.” They were all confused, yet surprised by their calmness in shooting. One of the soldiers even felt that he was shooting at an amusement part, trying to win a prize and target at human beings as if they were inanimate objects. Another veterans said, “We’re not murderers, but it the war, we all became murderers.” Sadness was delivered throughout the entire film. One soldier recalled the moment when he discovered a photo of two beautiful children amongst the belongings of a dead Egyptian officer. After the soldiers noticed the lost of humanity in the battlefields, they were ashamed because they carried themselves as patriotic heroes when they first entered the war. Equipped with the depressing voices of veterans, this film unfolds a personal insight on viewing the realities of wars.

CV_2.jpg

Mor Lousy, Amos Oz, and Avraham Shapira have further inspired me to conduct interviews and compile a short piece of writing in resemblance of my family members’ stories. It leads me to witness the greatness of personal narratives in formulating our worldview. Without this film, many of us cannot be aware of the soldiers’ torment and the destructive impacts of wars. Storytelling empowers people as it opens up conversations, informs the public of unknown narratives, and exchanges thoughts across different groups of people. It gives the victims an outlet to express their grievances and the perpetrators a chance to explain their motives.

Even though censorship is still a burden on the shoulders of many people in China, artists such as Mo Yan and Ai Weiwei are constantly seeking opportunities to publicize their concerns and criticism over the government’s stance on democracy and human rights. I hope to find a way to collect these unknown stories. They do not have to be published now, maybe later in the future, but it is worthwhile to unleash some of previously censored voices. Therefore, I am immensely excited to announce that, in the following two weeks, I have scheduled two interviews. One of them is with my grandmother who was born in 1949, the year the People’s Republic of China was established, and experienced the Cultural Revolution, and the other is with a family friend, a well-known scholar in Beijing. I am looking forward to these interviews and the information that I can gather from them!

Work Cited

Censored Voices. Dir. Mor Loushy. KNow Productions, 2015. DVD.

Images

https://independentseminarblog.files.wordpress.com/2016/10/2faf2-cv12.jpg

http://www.musicboxfilms.com/filebin/films/censored_voices/CV_2.jpg

3 thoughts on “Movie Review: “Censored Voices” | Sophie Xi

  1. Max D.

    Just a random idea: it would be incredibly interesting if you could compare your incoming interviews to the views of some published works that would have been censored in China. I’d definitely like to hear more about censorship and works that are done under it.

    Reply
  2. kevinwang11

    Censored voices are an integral part of literature as represent alternative perspectives. I really appreciate the part where you explain this notion with the documentary “Censored Voices.” I also look forward to seeing the results of your interviews!

    Reply
  3. margaretjhaviland

    How have the released interviews been received in Israel? Are people open to what these stories have to say or are there generational differences? After you do your interviews, will you choose to keep them to yourself or will you consider ways of sharing them or at least incorporating what you learn into your final product?

    What do you think of Israel’s government’s decision to censor and keep these stories hidden in a society that is a democracy and protects “speech” in its constitution.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s