Educational difference week 3

While I am finishing reading “The Learning Gap” and starting on a new book “The Japanese Education System”, I found the environment growing and changing really rapidly. Besides reading the books, I have also checked some recent news studies of American researchers in Asia. I believe researchers must have a sense of contradiction. Although all tests and examinations show that average Asian students have more academic knowledge than the average of American students, Asian students rarely like their education. Perhaps because of peer and family pressure, Asian students want to learn a diversity of skills outside of academics. Consequently, they admire US education, which promotes a lot of extracurricular activities and education in different aspects of life.

The teachers in schools also admire US education for the same reasons. So while the teachers and the researchers in the US think Asia has a better education because of its academic excellence, Asian teachers think US education is better because of the diversity of school curriculum.

Furthermore, Japan’s group-based education is somewhat related to its own cultural habits of thinking that everyone should be pushed under the same pressure to grow. Students in Japan are rarely told to be special and stand out in a crowd because according to a Japanese proverb. “Kyoboku kaze oshi” which means “Tall tree catch much wind”. The culture itself tell Japanese students to be humble and stay low.

— Eric Lin

2 thoughts on “Educational difference week 3

  1. margaretjhaviland

    I am curious what you think about when you think about in terms of differences in population? For instance the US has approximately just under three times as many people as Japan and a very different approach to education. Students in suburban school districts, some elite urban districts and and any number of private schools in the US more than hold their own in any test against their peers in China, Japan, and Taiwan. So do the measures your authors are looking at really matter? You did mention cultural differences, how much do these figure in and what do them mean for comparisons? Are there meaningful comparisons in terms of quality and outcome or just differences?

  2. shuangchengdu

    Many people, including me, usually have the stereotypes that Asian students such as Chinese and Japanese students are spending more time learning academic knowledge and less time doing extra curricular activities. Therefore, to me, Chinese students and Japanese students are starting with a higher position on academics while heading into college. Yet why would most technology breakthroughs and high-level academic achievements happen in Western countries like America instead of Asian countries?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.